Expert Witness Blog
In Experts – Be Wary of What You Post Online construction site expert witness William Gulya, Jr., President & CEO, Middlesex Trenching Company, writes:
Recently I followed a discussion wherein an expert was seeking opinions on how to best present a complex testing method in his report to a jury. Several experts responded, each with his or her advice and opinion. However, as the discussion progressed, it became a debate on the types of testing methods and the accuracy of each, the point of the original question (how to best present and explain the expert’s findings) quickly getting lost. The ramification of these experts publicizing their opinions on the testing methods – possibly being used against them in their future cases – was ignored.
A good policy is to keep any questions and queries to other experts private. You can call experts you know. You can even look up experts on the Internet and call them. You will find that most are willing to extend professional courtesy to you by sharing their experience on the question at hand. But do not use email, as it is discoverable as well.
Overzealous attorneys will look to discredit experts for even the most innocent discussions. They will take a discussion out of context and twist it around in an attempt to score a few unearned, unjust points with the jury. Experts need to be aware of this and be prepared to address and justify any exchanges/dialogues/discourse on the matter. (Also note that, in some cases, you must not under any circumstances discuss cases with anyone other than your staff.)
William Gulya, Jr., President & CEO, Middlesex Trenching Company for more than 35 years, specializes in excavation & construction site preparation – earthwork and grading, water mains, sewer installation, trenching, containment, underground utilities, dike repair, heavy equipment rentals. www.siteworkexpert.com